Intellectual Property High Court, 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10059 [Glass] <Kanno>
Updated: 1 hour ago
Article information
Article type: Case note
Classification: Patents
Issues: Support requirement, Numerical limitations and parameters
First published on this website: 2026-11-20
Case numbers: 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10059 / 2016 (Gyo-Ke) 10189
Display and classification checked: 2026-11-21
Article date: 2023-08-17
Intellectual Property High Court, 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10059 [Glass] <Kanno>
* The court identified the invention's problem as distinct from its physical-property requirements, and held that it was unnecessary for a product meeting the composition requirements to be likely to meet the physical-property requirements.
⇒ Glass meeting the composition requirements but not the physical-property requirements simply falls outside the claims.
Distinguished from Intellectual Property High Court, 2016 (Gyo-Ke) 10189 [Optical Glass] <Tsuruoka>!!
[Claim 1] ... Glass that is oxide glass having a liquidus temperature of 1140°C or below, a glass transition temperature of 672°C or above, a refractive index nd in the range of 1.825–1.850, and an Abbe number νd of 41.5–44
(Extract from the court's reasoning)
The plaintiff argues ... that some glass meets the composition requirements but not the physical-property requirements, making it impossible to find a correlation between satisfying the two sets of requirements ... .
However, the invention's problems are ... to further enhance the usefulness of high-refractive-index, low-dispersion glass by reducing the proportions of Gd, Ta, and Yb in its composition; to provide glass with superior thermal stability; and to provide glass suitable for machining. It seeks to solve those problems by adopting a configuration satisfying both the composition and physical-property requirements.
Accordingly, the composition and physical-property requirements cannot be said to stand in a problem-and-solution relationship. It is therefore unnecessary to recognize a relationship under which glass defined by the composition requirements has a high probability of satisfying every physical-property requirement, including glass transition temperature. The claims cover glass satisfying both sets of requirements; they do not assert that, throughout the entire numerical ranges of the composition requirements, every glass satisfying those requirements also satisfies the physical-property requirements. Any glass meeting the former but not the latter simply falls outside the claims. Moreover, in light of the numerical ranges described as preferred in the specification and the reasons for selecting them, it is difficult to find the composition ranges excessively broad. ...
(The plaintiff argues that the support requirement should be assessed here using the standard stated in another IP High Court judgment (Ko 7): ‘A person skilled in the art can recognize, from the description or suggestions in the detailed description or common general technical knowledge at the filing date, that the optical glass defined by the composition requirements is highly likely to satisfy the physical-property requirements.’ However, support must be assessed in relation to the invention's problem. In that other judgment, the problem was ‘providing optical glass with specified optical constants, a high refractive index and high dispersion, and a small partial dispersion ratio.’ It is inappropriate simply to apply to this case reasoning given as a fact-specific determination concerning a different problem in a different invention.)
Related articles
Update history
This history records changes actually made to publication, display, and classification on this website.
20 November 2026: First published on this website.
21 November 2026: Article type, classification, issues, related articles, consultation links, and SEO were maintained. The original text was not changed.
Comments