top of page

Intellectual Property High Court, 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10029 [Antiglare Film] <Shoji>

1 day ago
3 min read

Updated: 1 hour ago

Article information

Article type: Case note

Classification: Patents

Issues: Enablement, Support requirement, Clarity, Inventive step, Numerical limitations and parameters

First published on this website: 2026-11-20

Case numbers: 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10029

Display and classification checked: 2026-11-21


Article date: 2023-08-11


Intellectual Property High Court, 2022 (Gyo-Ke) 10029 [Antiglare Film] <Shoji>

① Enablement upheld even if the embodiments described in the specification include shapes and structures outside the claims (support requirement also upheld)

② Measurement conditions are inherently subject to limits, and a person skilled in the art measures reasonably ⇒ Clarity requirement satisfied

③ Where two parameters are interrelated, the court found no suggestion to adjust only one parameter of the primary cited invention independently of the other ⇒ Inventive step upheld

[Claim 1] "An antiglare film ... having a haze value within the range of 60% to 95%, inclusive, and an internal haze value within the range of 0.5% to 8.0%, inclusive."

(Extract from the court's reasoning)

① Even if some antiglare films obtainable by the first embodiment cannot be made by the second or third embodiment, this does not negate the ability to work the inventions through the first embodiment. Even if some second-structure antiglare layers made by the second embodiment and third-structure antiglare layers made by the third embodiment have shapes and structures different from the first-structure antiglare layer and do not satisfy the inventions' three optical characteristics, this merely means that those layers do not embody the inventions; it does not negate enablement of the inventions.

② ... A person skilled in the art would seek to set measurement conditions to avoid fluctuations in the results. There is no evidence showing that conditions avoiding fluctuations cannot be set when obtaining the standard deviation of the luminance distribution in the inventions. Moreover, ... it cannot be supposed that a person skilled in the art would measure ... luminance distribution under conditions that produce a marked divergence from the sparkle perceived by display users. Accordingly, permissible conditions for measuring luminance distribution in the inventions are subject to limits, such as setting them so that results for the same antiglare film remain constant without fluctuation. A person skilled in the art can be inferred to set and measure under conditions within a reasonable range subject to those limits. ...

③ Difference 1-1: In Invention 1 the "antiglare layer" has "an internal haze value within the range of 0.5% to 8.0%, inclusive," whereas the cited invention's "internal haze value" is unknown. ...

Reference 2 ... states that specifying surface haze more specifically expresses the degree of unevenness (the surface diffusion element). ... The surface haze value defines the shape of the unevenness, which is technically inseparable from sparkle, so Reference 2 cannot be understood as suggesting adjustment of sparkle independently of surface haze. ... Well-Known Reference A1 also states that "internal haze is preferably 5–30%," but also states that "surface haze is preferably 20–50%." ... It therefore does not suggest adjusting sparkle independently of surface haze either.

Update history

This history records changes actually made to publication, display, and classification on this website.

20 November 2026: First published on this website.

21 November 2026: Article type, classification, issues, related articles, consultation links, and SEO were maintained. The original text was not changed.

Comments


Featured Posts

Recent Posts

Archive
Search by Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
bottom of page